Ashley will take Moat’s £80m, but only if it is paid upfront.
Posted on October 19th, 2009 | 33 Comments |
Mike Ashley is now prepared to take £80m for Newcastle United but will there be any takers?
Amidst another petulant stab at the fans in yesterday’s Times, Mike Ashley announced:
“Barry Moat has been driving me mad for two years. If he wants to buy the club, he’s got a one-off opportunity to come up with the cash – £80m upfront.”
So one question is: can he or anyone else find the money? Another might be: is Newcastle United worth £80m?
The Times speculates that Barry Moat has agreed to pay the £80m that Ashley’s asking, but not ‘upfront’. Apparently Moat wants to pay £40m now and £40m at the end of the season. It’s anyone’s guess as to why Barry Moat wants to do things like this. Perhaps he has only been guaranteed the second £40m from his backers if Newcastle gets promoted, although that would be a huge risk for Barry Moat to take because if we didn’t manage promotion and the funds didn’t materialise then Moat is stuck with an outstanding £40m debt that, it seems, he won’t be able to pay.
Maybe Moat does have £80m in backing now but maybe that’s all he has, meaning that if he paid that upfront he’d have no operational cash and no money to spend on players, so perhaps he’s relying on promotion again to fund the remainder of his debt to Ashley. If this is the case we really have to wonder whether Barry Moat can actually afford to buy the club.
I can see why Ashley wouldn’t be too keen on the £40m now/£40m later idea. Sure, Moat would owe him the £40m and Ashley could sue for it if necessary, but there’s little point suing someone who can’t possibly pay. I’m as keen to see the back of Ashley as most fans are but I can’t blame him for asking for the £80m upfront. As Ashley put it:
“I have to put £20m a year into the club — I spend more than every other fan put together puts into the club each year. If you can’t pay upfront to buy the club, you can’t afford it.”
Take out the childish, ignorant and unnecessary pop at the fans and he’s right. The asking price was £100m, Ashley has ‘compromised’ on that price and will take £80m, so there’s your deal – take it or leave it.
As to whether the Toon is worth £80m, I am similar to Mike Ashley in that I’m no expert on football clubs, but £100m seemed to me to be a lot for a Championship club with a threadbare squad, an overdraft and a high wage bill during a recession. £80m seems more reasonable but I do admit I have no real concept of a football club’s ‘worth’.
The Times suggests that a rival South African consortium is also in the reckoning and they’re currently performing a due diligence, so maybe Barry Moat isn’t the only option.
I do however think it’s unlikely that the club will be sold this season. I suspect Ashley will give it a few more weeks then take it off the market – or at least put the sale on the back-burner – and appoint Chris Hughton as manager for the rest of the season (but Ashley will retain the final say on players, he claims). Then – promotion or no promotion – it’s a matter of waiting to see what happens next season.
Morning Hugh
This guy seems to have learnt nothing from the past two years regarding handling the fans. Why make the petty, childish, unnecesary remarks regarding him putting in more each season than the fans. It makes him sound petulant and spiteful.
I agree with you, his overall argument regarding Moat is sound, but then he turns the spotlight away from that very real debate by including unnecessary comments to have a dig at the fans. What a clown.
Going back to the Moat issue. If as fatty states, he has wanted to buy the club for 2 years, why hasn’t he? It’s clear he can’t afford it. If he can’t afford it he should shut up and leave well alone. The last thing we need is to lurch from one disaster to another to satisfy another man’s ego.